So after being 'Bigged' up from the stadium announcer twice pre match what are your opinions on his debut?
My view...
-At fault for the first goal after he failed to SEND the pass in the right position.
-Runs like Camara
-Looked better at going forward than defending
-Was obvious he wasn't going to play the 90 today.
-needs match practise(understandable)
- I doubt he will start on Tuesday.
Overall an ok attacking performance but looked weak on the ball at the back and needs more match fitness.
Give him a chance though- you know how good Camara got!
Was wrong decision to start him, clearly wasnt up to it physically. He clearly looks used to playing quick passes and keeping the ball on the deck, which we seen little of yesterday. It will take him a while to adapt to the way we play, and for him to cement his role within the team. He will turn out to be a good signing in the long run though, im sure.
Agree he looked good going forward but not so sure in defence.
However, for that I blame Robbo who played him into difficult positions especially when he gave the ball to Bensherrif for him to score the first goal.
Not match fit and so for that we must blame the manager.
Agree he looked good going forward but not so sure in defence.
However, for that I blame Robbo who played him into difficult positions especially when he gave the ball to Bensherrif for him to score the first goal.
Not match fit and so for that we must blame the manager.
Agree with all. He looked promising going forward, but not at the back. Could be a good winger? I hope Bucks plays Charnock and Robbo back at RB on Tuesday. But it's only one game he's had, lets give him a chance.
Modgull wrote:Agree he looked good going forward but not so sure in defence.
However, for that I blame Robbo who played him into difficult positions especially when he gave the ball to Bensherrif for him to score the first goal.
Not match fit and so for that we must blame the manager.
Agree with the above. Playing Senda over Charnock may have been about underestimating the opposition.
I can't comment on Senda's performance as I didn't attend the game, but it was obviously his sloppy pass that led to the first goal. Buckle commented last week that he needed three reserve games to get match fit, so I'm not sure why he was thrown into the deep end when we had an alternative option. Which brings me to my next point...
...Charnock. He's waited patiently for a chance to break back into the team after doing very little wrong in the first place. Unfortunately for him, Ellis and Branston have formed an unbreakable partnership. But to remain glued to the bench despite Ellis being unavailable must be a huge kick in the teeth. I understand that both the Pickler and Charnock are left-footed, but that looked a better option than playing a half-fit Senda and shifting Robertson inside.
I'm hoping Charnock gets the nod on Tuesday if Ellis is still injured. If not, then he'll be off in January. And you couldn't blame him for wanting out.
Senda is an 'attacking' full-back. And with all due respect to Macclesfield, yesterday's game was an ideal time to blood him. Charnock was less then solid in the reserves on Tuesday too, so probably did himself little favours in that one.
With regards to his performance, he looked, as you'd probably expect, decent going forward but less solid than Robbo defensively. I'm afraid if you instruct a full-back to get forward at every opportunity, you are naturally going to be more stretched defensively than you would be if you had a full-back that didn't cross the half way line.
"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something."
YellowMurphy wrote:Was wrong decision to start him, clearly wasnt up to it physically. He clearly looks used to playing quick passes and keeping the ball on the deck, which we seen little of yesterday. It will take him a while to adapt to the way we play, and for him to cement his role within the team. He will turn out to be a good signing in the long run though, im sure.
I did wonder, on Saturday, whether this is testing the water with Senda at RB and Robbo back in the middle in case Ellis goes in January...let's face it, when Ellis is fit, he will go straight back into the team, so this was a chance to see how that worked out.
